ARTICLE

The Argument Is About Jews, Not Metal Detectors

News Image By Jonathan S. Tobin/JNS.org July 24, 2017
Share this article:

To an objective observer, the crisis that erupted in the aftermath of a bloody terror attack near Jerusalem's Temple Mount makes no sense.

Three Arab terrorists used guns they had smuggled up to the compound July 14 to kill two Israeli policemen, both of whom happened to be Druze rather than Jewish. In response, Israeli authorities set up metal detectors to prevent a recurrence of the crime.

The response to this from Palestinians was general outrage, violence and a promise of mass riots if the offending machines were not immediately removed. Upon Friday afternoon prayers July 21, with Israel facing the prospect of even more violence that might get out of control, the metal detectors remained in place.

How could putting metal detectors to protect a holy site be considered a casus belli for what might, if the conflict escalated in the way the Muslim rioters promised, lead to a new holy war?


The answer is that this Isn't about metal detectors. It's about something much bigger: the right of Jews to be in Jerusalem.

This isn't another variation on the usual theme sounded from Israel's critics about the infringement of Palestinian rights. To the contrary, Israel didn't change the status quo at the Temple Mount, which denies Jews the right to pray at the holiest place in Judaism.

The Islamic Waqf was left in charge of Jerusalem's mosques, including the Temple Mount's Al-Aqsa, inviolate.

Nor was the new security measure discriminatory. Any Jew or non-Jew who wishes to enter the Western Wall plaza below the Temple Mount compound must also pass through security, including metal detectors. The same is true for Muslims who wish to enter the holy places in Mecca during their annual pilgrimages.

So what exactly is this all about?


For a century, Palestinian Arab leaders have been playing the "Al-Aqsa is in danger" card. The cries that Jews were seeking to destroy the mosques or in some way harm Muslim rights led to a series of pogroms against Jews, including the riots of 1929 in which Jews were massacred in Hebron.

But the appeal to holy war isn't only a vestige of the horrors of the distant past and the influence of the Nazi sympathizer Haj Amin al-Husseini, the mufti of Jerusalem who incited those riots.

It was the supposedly moderate Mahmoud Abbas, president of the Palestinian Authority (PA), whose inflammatory statements helped incite the so-called "stabbing intifada" in recent years by also claiming Jews were going to harm the mosques.

It was Abbas, not just his Hamas rivals or other violent Islamists, who called on Palestinians to resist the Jewish presence in Jerusalem. It was Abbas who said "stinking Jewish feet" should not profane the holy places.

Abbas's motives were cynical, since he was waving the bloody banner of holy war to compete with his political foes. But the impact of his statements gave the lie to the notion--so prevalent on the Jewish left--that a peace agreement could be easily reached if Israel had the will to try for one.

His rhetoric sought to remind Palestinians that the conflict wasn't over borders or settlements, but something far more basic: a religious war that mandates Arab opposition to the Jewish presence.

This is why the PA goes to such trouble to foment fights at United Nations agencies like UNESCO intended to deny Jewish ties or rights to holy places, even those that are self-evidently proof of Jewish history like the Temple Mount and the Western Wall.

This is also why the new security measures are merely the latest pretext for Arab violence intended to make the point that Jews should not merely have no say over the Temple Mount, but have no right to be there at all.

The demonstrations and threats of more violence are just one more power play intended to remind the world that the only solution Palestinians will ultimately accept is one in which the Jews are excluded.

So long as this is their goal, it isn't Al-Aqsa that is in danger, but any hope for peace.

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

April 17, 2024Will Israel Target Iranian Oil Infrastructure? Gas Prices Already On The Rise

Can you imagine paying seven dollars for a gallon of gasoline? It could soon happen, because it appears that Israel is about to strike Ir...

April 17, 2024Report: $100,000 Income Now Needed In All 50 States To Live 'American Dream'

Is your family bringing in more than $100,000 a year? If not, "the American Dream" is not for you according to a new report. ...

April 17, 2024Surgeons Face New Challenge As Gender Dysphoria Paves Way To Body Dysphoria

In what is called the first described case of "digits amputation," Canadian doctors surgically removed two healthy fingers from a young ma...

April 17, 2024Scotland's Transgender Hate Crime Law Already Showing How It Leads To Tyranny

Scotland's new "hate crime" law already is demonstrating how it will be used to squash dissent and free speech. And who decides what exact...

April 16, 2024Middle East Update - What Next?

There are reasonable arguments to be made for Israel to think carefully about the kind of response to Iran's decision to escalate the ongo...

April 16, 2024Multiple Global Pestilences Threaten To Spiral Completely Out Of Control

Do you remember the nightmares that we experienced in 2020 and 2021? Nobody wants to go through anything like that again, but right now m...

April 16, 2024A Resounding Strategic Failure For Iran

The fact that 99% of the threats were intercepted means that a central pillar of Iranian force projection--its missile and UAV arsenals--h...

Get Breaking News