ARTICLE

1.77 Kids Aren't Enough: The Consequences Of A Shrinking Population

News Image By John Stonestreet/Breakpoint.org December 20, 2017
Share this article:

America is shrinking. I don't mean we're getting shorter, I mean that we aren't having enough babies. Here's why that's bad news.

An old Far Side cartoon by Gary Larson portrays an average American couple welcoming visitors to their home. In the corner of the living room sits a little boy watching TV and next to him, is half of another little boy. "Come on in!" exclaim the couple, "Have you met Russel and Bill, our 1.5 children?"

Larson's attempt to make fun of the American average, unfortunately, wasn't that far off. In fact, America's fertility rate may be hitting a historic low.


Lyman Stone, an economist at the U.S. Department of Agriculture, writes at Medium about what he's calling "the great baby bust of 2017."

The latest official estimate--taken from two-year-old data--puts the U.S. fertility rate at 1.84. In other words, the average American woman will have just under two children in her lifetime. This is well below the replacement rate, or the average number of children necessary to keep a country's population from declining.

But as Stone argues, this estimate is already hopelessly out-of-date. Using monthly birth data from 2016 and 2017, he suggests the birth rate in America has plummeted to somewhere near 1.77 births on average. His graph of American fertility since 2008 looks like a double diamond ski slope.

Millennials--who right now are in their prime childbearing years--are the ones mainly driving this downhill trend. Not only are they getting married at lower rates than their parents did, but they're having fewer children total. Many struggle to find stable work, are too focused on their careers, and find themselves saddled with college debt. 

Others just don't like kids,  or vastly overestimate the cost of raising them, or just think the world is overpopulated--a myth now thoroughly debunked, by the way.

Whatever the reason, young adults are choosing to keep their nests mostly empty. And this is bad news for our economy, our culture, and our future as a nation.


As Weekly Standard digital editor Jonathan Last writes in his book, "What to Expect When No One's Expecting," countries where citizens aren't having enough babies can look forward to long-term economic stagnation and social deterioration. 

"There is no economy that has managed to knock out gangbuster growth with a declining population," he told The Atlantic, recently.

Journalist Philip Longman explains that "As governments raise taxes on a dwindling working-age population to cover the growing burdens of supporting the elderly, young couples may conclude they are even less able to afford children..." 

This creates a vicious cycle of childlessness, overwork, and despair, as seen in graying, shrinking countries like Japan, or in Europe, where some governments actually pay couples to get pregnant.

Also, children, because they are tomorrow's labor force and consumers, are also the economic engines of the future. And on an individual level, the regret of having fewer children is verifiable. 

According to a Pew poll in 2014, a whopping 40 percent of mothers nearing the end of their childbearing years say they have fewer kids than they would have liked.

But that's not all: a declining population also hurts us in ways that are harder to quantify in dollars and cents.

Babies, in a unique way, tend to make adults care about the future that's beyond their own lifetimes. They're often the reason people save, invest, make sacrifices, and most importantly defer gratification. 

When children become scarce, people are less apt to do these things and therefore they stop thinking about a future that's beyond themselves.

In tomorrow's edition, my colleague Eric Metaxas will offer a glimpse into what that kind of future will look like, if the birth dearth continues. Please tune in.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

April 20, 2018Is There A Space War Coming, And Are We Ready For It?

According to the Outer Space Treaty, signed in 1967, space can only be used for peaceful purposes, and it doesn’t fall under the jurisdict...

April 20, 2018Russia And Israel, Seven Decades On

Amid all the diplomatic maneuverings in the months that led up to the creation of the State of Israel 70 years ago, none are more curious ...

April 20, 2018Are Christians Welcome in Public Life? Booker vs. Pompeo

Senator Booker has essentially said that believing historic Christian teaching on sexuality makes one unfit for public office in the Unite...

April 20, 2018Israel's Population Tops 8.8 Million On 70th Anniversary

Having increased tenfold since 1948, it is expected to reach 15.2 million by the 2048 centennial....

April 19, 2018Pathway To The Mark? Cashless Society Slowly Gaining Around The World

As electronic payment apps, debit cards and credit cards replace paper currency, governments, bank and corporations delight in the level o...

April 19, 2018The War Against Conservative & Religious Speech

The left is on a jihad against conservative thought. It’s happening in academia, entertainment, business, religion, everywhere....

April 19, 2018A New Bible Celebrating Israel's Role In The Fulfillment Of Prophecy

"The Israel Bible" is a brand new 2,200-page Bible that highlights the role of Israel in the fulfillment of Biblical prophecy....

Get Breaking News