ARTICLE

Sin or Sickness?: We Need Deliverance, Not Just Diagnosis

News Image By John Stonestreet/Breakpoint.org September 10, 2018
Share this article:

The increasing tendency to reclassify moral failures as "mental disorders" is troubling. Here's why Christians must resist the pressure to diminish moral guilt.

When students confess pornography addiction to me, I point them to the necessity of accountability, the importance of counseling, and other strategies that can help them overcome this bondage. 

But I also encourage them to repent, to confess their deeper bondage to sin--a bondage that started with a moral failure, the choice to click and to click again, and to click again. 

Their hope, I want them to know, is ultimately found in the grace of God, as proven in Christ Jesus, that God will forgive our sin and deliver us from it.

Few people today still think like this. There's a growing trend to describe sex addiction not as a sin, but as a sickness, like chicken pox or cancer or depression. And that trend has just become more official.

Recently, the USA Today reported that the World Health Organization has added "sex addiction" to its list of mental disorders. Many experts hope the new classification "will help change the disorder's perception from a moral failing to simply a medical issue." 

One addiction specialist even praised the World Health Organization for removing sex addiction from the realm of "morality" and "religion," and placing it in the realm of medicine.

The shift, according to the article, "resembles previous changes to how doctors viewed other addictive disorders, such as alcoholism, drug addiction or gambling." Which makes me wonder, are these things now outside the realm of morality and religion, too?

Even more interesting is the list of criteria the World Health Organization used to diagnose this new class of disorder. Clinical sex addicts must exhibit repetitive sexual activities that become the focus of their lives. They must also have made repeated and unsuccessful efforts to stop the behavior, while deriving little satisfaction from it.

But of course anyone addicted to pornography would say at least two of these things. Compulsive behavior, trouble getting free of the habit, lack of lasting satisfaction--those are not only signs of addiction, they're signs of chronic sin. None of these things prove that what we're dealing with is merely a sickness.

But calling it a sickness removes moral responsibility. Have you noticed how many public figures, when caught in sexual misconduct, quickly and predictably blame addiction or mental illness for their behavior? Most recently it was Mel B (aka "Scary Spice" of the Spice Girls) who, when exposed, checked into rehab, talked of her actions as not a moral failure, but a disease.

Now don't misunderstand me. In the process of rehabilitation from an addiction, medical and therapeutic interventions are often necessary and clearly helpful. Ample research shows that as a person engages in a particular behavior over and over again, neurological pathways are reinforced, making it even more difficult to change the behavior. 



The Bible reflects this reality, as well. The Apostle Paul described those in sin as being "slaves."

Our sin certainly can become an addiction, but that doesn't mean it no longer is a moral issue. Nor does it change the fact that, almost always, addiction begins with a moral choice.

That's why sin will never be an outdated concept. It's a deadly reality of fallen human existence, and to ignore it is to deny reality. We are moral agents in need of redemption and restoration, not just machines in need of a tune-up. Or as one of our writers, Leah Hickman, put it, the moral teaching of the Bible is not "all are sick," but "all have sinned."

The push to reclassify sexual addiction like pornography as a disease is what happens when we reduce all problems to physical causes. Materialist medicine alone, however, is incapable of breaking the power of sin over our lives. Only the Great Physician offers a lasting cure.

A Biblical resource that has helped thousands to break free of porn addiction is the Conquer Series which can be found here.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

February 21, 2019Will The U.S. Military Invade Venezuela?

We are getting dangerously close to war with Venezuela. Last month, 35-year-old Juan Guaido declared himself to be the new president of V...

February 21, 2019Was Today's Technology Foretold in the Bible?

Daniel couldn't possibly understand many end time prophecies because certain events and advancements in technology would have to happen fi...

February 21, 2019The Empty Planet: Population Bust, Not Population Bomb

Virtually every dire prediction Paul Ehrlich made fifty years ago in his book "The Population Bomb" was wrong. Spectacularly wrong, in fac...

February 21, 2019A Palestinian Terrorist Too Brutal For Fatah

The Palestinian Authority has finally found a terrorist act committed by a Palestinian against an Israeli that it wants to disassociate fr...

February 20, 2019How 1984 Turned Into An Instruction Manual

One of the key themes from George Orwell's dystopic novel 1984 is that the Party can do and say whatever it wants. And more importantly, y...

February 20, 2019The Progressive Mandela Effect

The "Mandela Effect," which is the Internet's way of describing shared false memories is named for the legions of armchair historians who ...

February 20, 2019The Kushner Compromise?

"Israeli compromises" will involve reducing Israel to nine miles wide at its mid-section. That's not even as wide as Washington, D.C., or ...

Get Breaking News