Five Years For Defending Christianity: Egypt’s Warning To The West
By PNW StaffNovember 19, 2026
Share this article:
Egypt’s highest appeals court has upheld a five-year prison sentence with hard labor for Coptic Christian researcher Augustinos Samaan. His case began with videos discussing and defending Christianity. The appeal was rejected on November 15, leaving the sentence in force.
That is the kind of sentence many Western Christians struggle to imagine: five years behind bars for speaking about the faith. But Samaan’s case is not an isolated warning. It is part of a wider reality in which Christians in Egypt can face criminal charges for religious speech, obstacles to worship, and violence that too often goes unanswered.
When Christian speech becomes a crime
Samaan was convicted under Article 98(f) of Egypt’s penal code, a law used in cases described as “contempt of religion.” The law’s language may sound like a safeguard against religious hatred. In practice, it can also give authorities broad power to punish people for expressing religious views.
Samaan’s videos addressed Christianity and responded to material circulating online. His lawyers said they were not properly notified of his trial and were denied timely access to the case file. The Court of Cassation’s decision now leaves him facing the maximum sentence under the law.
Other Christians have been arrested over online posts or religious expression. Coptic engineer Sherif Wagih Fahmi was detained after sharing material on Facebook. Six young Christians, including a minor, were charged after recreating a scene from an Egyptian comedy film. They were released pending proceedings, but the charges remain.
The question for Western Christians is simple: If explaining and defending the faith can be treated as an offense, how secure is religious freedom when the law gives the state power to decide which religious speech is acceptable?
Worship can come with a price
Egypt’s constitution recognizes Islam as the state religion and names Sharia principles as the primary source of legislation. It also recognizes freedom of belief, while the legal framework for public worship and building places of worship is restricted to Islam, Christianity and Judaism.
Even for recognized Christian communities, building or repairing a church can be difficult. Applications to legalize church buildings remain unresolved in many cases, and Copts have faced attacks when rumors spread that a home or property might be used for worship.
In several villages, mobs have attacked Christian homes and church property. Yet instead of seeing perpetrators held accountable, Christians have sometimes been pushed into “reconciliation” sessions supervised by local authorities. These settlements can leave Christian families paying fines, surrendering property, or even leaving their homes.
That is not reconciliation in any meaningful sense when the people who were attacked must bear the cost while the attackers escape justice. It teaches a dangerous lesson: that violence can succeed where the law should have protected a minority.
A reminder the West should not ignore
The pressure reaches beyond churches and online speech. Converts from Islam can face particular danger, including when they try to change the religion listed on official documents. Coptic women and girls have also disappeared in cases that advocacy groups say authorities have been reluctant to investigate fully.
These stories should unsettle Christians in the West—not because Egypt’s experience can be reduced to a single cause or applied simplistically to every Muslim, but because religious liberty is never guaranteed by good intentions alone. It depends on laws, institutions, and leaders willing to protect the rights of people whose beliefs are unpopular or in the minority.
Western Christians often speak freely, gather for worship, build churches, and share the gospel without expecting a prison sentence. That freedom is precious. It should make us more attentive to believers who lack it, not complacent about how easily rights can be restricted when authorities claim they are defending public order or protecting religion.
Samaan’s sentence is a warning about what happens when the state gains power to punish peaceful religious expression. Five years for defending Christianity should be impossible to shrug off. For Egypt’s Christians, it is a reminder of the price they may pay for their faith. For Christians in the West, it is a call to defend religious liberty before the same kinds of arguments begin to sound normal here.