ARTICLE

The Politics Of Appeasement - The 'National Security' Excuse

News Image By Stephen M. Flatow/JNS.org June 01, 2016
Share this article:

Ever wonder why it is that Congress passes so many strongly pro-Israel bills, yet they never seem to be implemented?


For example, a bill was passed to move the Embassy of the United States in Israel to Jerusalembut the embassy was never moved. Legislation was passed to restrict U.S. aid to the Palestinian Authority (PA)but it was never restricted. 

Now a bill has been passed to permit families of 9/11 victims to sue Saudi Arabiabut in fact, it will actually block such lawsuits.

What all three of these laws have in common is a deceptive little tactic called a national security waiver.

The Jerusalem Embassy Relocation Act was passed by Congress way back in 1995. Its author was Sen. Bob Dole. The bill required the president to move the American embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. Yet here we are, 21 years later, and its still in Tel Aviv.

The reason is because the Bill Clinton administration strongly opposed the bill. The White House demanded that a clause be added to permit the president to waive the embassy relocation requirement if he determined that moving the embassy would endanger Americas national security. 

How would it harm national security? Well, it might anger the Arab world, so apparently that constitutes a danger to our security.

Major pro-Israel organizations were afraid of clashing with Clinton, so they urged Dole to add the national security waiver. He did so. And every six months since 1995, the president has issued a statement invoking the waiver.

Maybe Clinton would have vetoed the Embassy Relocation Act if it had no such waiver. And maybe Congressional supporters of the legislation would not have had enough votes to override the veto. 

But it would have been better to have no such bill, than to have this fraud, in which the pro-Israel community pretends that it achieved some kind of victory, when in fact it suffered a total defeat.

Something very similar happened with the Middle East Peace Facilitation Act (MEPFA), which was first enacted following the 1993 Oslo Accords, in order to authorize U.S. government funding to the PA.

Some Zionist organizations lobbied to include a clause making the aid conditional on the PAs compliance with the provisions of the Oslo agreement. Sen. Arlen Specter added that clause. But then the Clinton administration demanded the addition of language to neuter Specters amendment. 


Once again, pro-Israel organizations went along with the administrations demand. And so Specter consented to adding a stipulation that if the president certifies that the PA is compliance, the aid goes through.

So every six months, the president lies: He claims the PA is in compliance, even though it has consistently violated every major provision of the accords (such as incitement, sheltering terrorists, and refusing to extradite fugitive terroriststo cite just three of the most glaring examples).

Claiming that MEPFA increased restrictions on the aid or held [Yasser] Arafats feet to the fire might sound good in a fund-raising appeal. But such bragging masks the sad reality that aid to the PA continues to flow, and American Jewish organizations have not stopped it. 

Maybe Clinton would have vetoed MEPFA without the certification clause. And maybe Congress would not have been able to override it. But having no bill would have been better than pretending that something was actually done to restrict U.S. aid to the PA.

And now here we go again. The Senate recently passed legislation that would enable families of 9/11 victims to sue the government of Saudi Arabia if it is found that the Saudis helped sponsor the attack. The Obama administration, trying to shield the Saudis from lawsuits, opposes the bill. 

So this week, Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) quietly inserted an amendment that allows the secretary of state to block any lawsuit arising from the bill if the administration deems the suit harmful to national security. You can be sure that the secretary of state will invoke that clause at every opportunity.

The national security excuse was used to block the moving of the U.S. embassy in Israel, because it would anger the Arabs. It was used to block restrictions on aid to the PA, because it would anger the Arabs. And now it will be used to block lawsuits that might anger the Arabs.

How long will justice be held captive to such policies of timidity and appeasement?

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

July 09, 2025From Japan To The U.S - Earthquake Fault Lines Are Awakening

Is there a possibility that a cataclysmic eruption of Mt. Rainier could occur in the not too distant future? On Tuesday morning, Mt. Rain...

July 09, 2025When The Left Wants Blood: The Quiet Slide Toward Political Violence

Democratic lawmakers are hearing increasingly violent rhetoric from their constituents-calls to "break the rules," "fight dirty," and stop...

July 09, 2025The Digital Trap: Europe's Quiet March Toward Total Control

Imagine a world where every transaction you make, every website you visit, every thought you dare to express online is silently recorded, ...

July 09, 2025Shepherds Without Scripture: What Do Today’s Pastors Really Believe?

One in four Mainline clergy doubt the existence of God. These aren't fringe bloggers or deconstructing TikTok influencers. These are the m...

July 07, 2025Hijacking Creation: Scientists May Only Be Years Away From Lab-Made Children

In-vitro gametogenesis - the creation of human sperm and eggs from skin or blood cells--is now just years away. Scientists across Japan, C...

July 07, 2025Death To The IDF? The Disturbing New Normal On The Progressive Left

Once reliably pro-Israel, the Democratic Party has undergone a dramatic reversal on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict-and no demographic re...

July 07, 2025Access Denied: How Age Rules Could Reshape The Internet For Everyone

If identity becomes the new key to the internet, then the next great digital debate won't be about content moderation-it will be about acc...

Get Breaking News