ARTICLE

Pro-Choice Movement Goes After The Ultrasound

News Image By Eric Metaxas/Breakpoint.org February 11, 2017
Share this article:

Imagine being told that microscopes falsely "advance the idea" that bacteria and viruses cause disease. Or what if someone told you that telescopes falsely "advance the idea" that galaxies exist? 

You'd think that person was a few fries short of a happy meal, right?

Well that's exactly the sort of argument Moira Weigel made at The Atlantic last month in an article originally entitled--I'm not kidding: "How Ultrasound Advanced the Idea that a Fetus is a Person." 

I say "originally," because the title has since been changed to the much less provocative, "How Ultrasound Became Political."

Either way, Weigel's point in this bizarre rant against medical technology is to convince readers that ultrasound imaging does not, in fact, reveal babies in the womb. 


Rather, it's a tool pro-lifers have used to dupe women into seeing fetuses as human beings.

She begins by recounting ultrasound's origin as a weapon in submarine warfare--a weapon that men soon turned from the ocean's briny depths "toward women's bodies."

"Ultrasound," Weigel opines, "made it possible for the male doctor to evaluate the fetus without female interference," (as if women never become doctors).

"The framing of the ultrasound,"--again, this is a quote--"was notable for what it excluded: the woman. In order to make the fetus visible, it made her disappear." I'm not making this up.

Weigel argues that the form on an ultrasound screen isn't meaningfully different from the "rapidly dividing cell mass" of early pregnancy. 

"The current debate," she writes, "shows how effectively politicians have used visual technology to redefine what counts as 'life.'"

Even social media, it seems, is part of this conspiracy to humanize the unborn. 

Expectant parents who post black-and-white or 3D images of their babies on Facebook and Instagram are willing accomplices in this propaganda, suggests Weigel, who makes no effort to mask her disdain for this "popular enthusiasm for fetal images."

This article was, to put it bluntly, an editor's nightmare. 

In the days following its publication, it's undergone major revisions, introducing a towering list of corrections about when a baby's heart starts beating, when it has reflexes, major mistakes about the stories of those featured in the article, etc. As of this recording, the editor's note was over 170 words long.


Now look, I'm not going to pretend we here at BreakPoint have never made mistakes. We have! And we correct them whenever they're identified. But the sheer volume of error in this deeply weird attack on medical technology leads me to believe it was written to obscure the truth, not reveal it.

Weigel is right that ultrasound has been instrumental in the pro-life movement. Pregnancy care centers report that nearly eighty percent of abortion-minded women choose life after seeing their babies on screen. 

A 2014 study of Los Angeles Planned Parenthood clinics found that a statistically significant number of women who had already made abortion appointments changed their minds after seeing their babies.

And organizations like Save the Storks report that four out of five women who accept their free ultrasound service choose life.

Ultrasound is instrumental in the fight against abortion precisely because it allows women to make an informed choice by shedding light in a place which, for most of its history, has been shrouded in secrecy. 

And when the pro-choice camp rails so angrily against the light technology has shed, it almost seems like they prefer the darkness.

Perhaps what they see on that monitor troubles them. And you know what? It should.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

June 14, 2019Academic Battles: Statement Of Faith vs. Statement Of Diversity

Despite leftist academia condemning Christian schools and organizations for their statement of faith requirement, they see no irony in enf...

June 14, 2019The Victims Of Words: Reality Isn't Whatever We Want

Many today imagine they've got mastery over reality--not with the use of a stone, but through words. Redefining words, they think, would m...

June 14, 2019Israeli Author Tour Highlights Israel & US Intertwined Values

In early 2019, author David Rubin left Israel for the United States of America on a mission to showcase his new book, Trump and the Jews, ...

June 13, 2019Why I Do Not Celebrate Gay Pride

If you ask my detractors, they would tell you that the reason I do not celebrate gay pride is that I'm a bigot. A hater. A homophobe. A tr...

June 13, 2019Messianic Believers Come Under Fire In Israel

As the number of Messianic Jews in Israel has risen to about 30,000 and as the society at large is much more open to these Jewish believer...

June 13, 2019When Europe Is No Longer Europe: The Irreversible Decline

Populist movements will have little weight in the new European Parliament; the Greens are gaining ground; Islamization will not stop, and ...

June 13, 2019Thirty Years After The Tiananmen Square Massacre - A Warning Of The Future

The Communist Party that ruthlessly murdered thousands of Chinese students thirty years ago this week are still in power and they are in c...

Get Breaking News