ARTICLE

Why the Masterpiece Cake Case Matters To All Americans

News Image By Michael Brown/Ask Dr Brown December 04, 2017
Share this article:

Should a gay baker be required by law to design a cake with the message, "God hates fags"? Should an African American t-shirt maker be required by law to design a t-shirt saying, "Long live the KKK?" 

Should a Muslim caterer be required by law to provide pork for a secular event? Should a Jewish photographer be required to shoot a wedding on the Sabbath? The answer to all these questions is: Of course not. 

Why, then, should a Christian baker be required by law to design a cake celebrating the "wedding" of two women (or men)?


That is the big question the Supreme Court will be answering next week when it hears the Masterpiece Cakes case involving Christian baker Jack Phillips.

The Alliance Defending Freedom, which is defending Phillips, has pointed out that: 1) "Jack does not discriminate," and he was perfectly happy to sell the gay couple, who subsequently took him to court, cookies and brownies and anything else pre-made off of his shelves; 

2) "Jack has turned down other cakes in the past," including Halloween cakes and lewd cakes; 

3) "Jack has faced anti-religious bigotry as well as threats and intimidation simply because he declined to promote an event," so he is the one being singled out for unfair treatment; 

4) "Jack owns a private family business, and he doesn't give up his rights when he sells his art," and by calling his business "Masterpiece Cakes," he is making clear that for him, they are works of art; 

5) accordingly, "Jack's shop has been called an 'art gallery of cakes'"; and 

6) "Wedding cakes made up about 40 percent of Jack's business," and these are all custom designed. But due to Colorado's laws and legal rulings to date, he has had to drop this part of his business entirely.

Now, common sense would say that this case should be a no-brainer, a slam-dunk win for Jack Phillips and his attorneys. And in principle, I agree. 

The problem, however, is that "gay rights" have been exalted to such a degree that these "rights" trump all other rights and freedoms, including our freedoms of conscience, speech, and religion.

In the case at hand, because Phillips is a committed Christian, he doesn't make cases mixed with alcohol (nor can he be required to), he doesn't make cakes for lewd bachelor parties (nor can he be required to), and he doesn't make cakes for horror-themed events (nor can he be required to). 

But when he cannot, in good conscience, use his artistic skills to make a cake for a same-sex "wedding," he can be charged with violating the state's anti-discrimination laws to the point that the state can now discriminate against him as a Christian.

Put another way, you can freely exercise your Christian beliefs unless those beliefs offend gays. In that case, you're breaking the law.

And what if a Hindu came in and wanted a, "Krishna is Lord" cake? Phillips could politely decline, without legal penalty or pressure. The same with a Muslim baker declining to bake a cake for a Christian with the words, "Jesus is Lord."

But wouldn't that offend the Hindu and the Christian wanting to buy the cakes? Perhaps so, but the bakers are rightly protected by the law and cannot be penalized for refusing the business.

Why, then, are gays and lesbians treated differently? Why are they put in a special category?

The sympathetic answer would be that society has overcompensated for perceived past injustices. And so, the pendulum has swung from one side (mistreatment of gays and lesbians) to the other side (overprotection of gays and lesbians).

The more realistic answer is that some gay activists have always had as their ultimate goal the silencing of those who resist their cause.

As I've said for more than a decade, those who came out of the closet want to put us in the closet. And as a Christian attorney once commented to me, "Those who were once put in jail want to put us in jail."

In the days ahead, many on the left will argue that Phillips was guilty of discriminating against gay customers. But that is a complete misrepresentation of the facts, and if the Supreme Court finds him guilty, the implications for America will be massive.

It will mean that the highest court in the land has ruled that, in virtually all conceivable cases, gay rights trump religious rights. And it will mean that Christians in particular can be forced to violate their consciences and their deeply held, historic beliefs under penalty of law, with the real potential of losing their very livelihoods. 

And should they still refuse to comply, it could mean a jail sentence too.

While some on the left (including LGBT activists) will say, "This is not what we intended," plenty of others will gloat. After all, if we deserved to be thrown to the lions in one generation, it's no big deal to imprison us in another generation.

I'm hoping that the Supreme Court does the right thing. If not, my leftist readers may mock my words today but you will mark them tomorrow.

Originally published at AskDrBrown.org - reposted with permission.


Other News

April 19, 2018Pathway To The Mark? Cashless Society Slowly Gaining Around The World

As electronic payment apps, debit cards and credit cards replace paper currency, governments, bank and corporations delight in the level o...

April 19, 2018The War Against Conservative & Religious Speech

The left is on a jihad against conservative thought. It’s happening in academia, entertainment, business, religion, everywhere....

April 19, 2018A New Bible Celebrating Israel's Role In The Fulfillment Of Prophecy

"The Israel Bible" is a brand new 2,200-page Bible that highlights the role of Israel in the fulfillment of Biblical prophecy....

April 19, 2018Israel: 70 Years Of Miracles

A century ago, even after the Balfour Declaration gave the Zionist movement its first real triumph, the notion of a Jewish state in what w...

April 18, 2018Israel Braces For Iranian Counterstrike

Tehran is now believed to be preparing for a sustained campaign of direct confrontation with Israel, with plans to use the Iranian militar...

April 18, 20183 Questions Regarding Our Bombing of Syria

Reactions to our bombing of Syria have been intense on all sides. Why are some Trump supporters outraged with the president's actions? Why...

April 18, 2018Social Media Now Being Used By Intelligence Agencies To Collect Biometrics

We are clearly picking up steam down the slippery slope as we are being converted from human beings into digital algorithms where our enti...

Get Breaking News