California Prepares To Crack Down On Homeschoolers

News Image By Rachel Blevins/Free Thought Project February 06, 2018
Share this article:

Lawmakers in the state of California are now pushing for families who homeschool their children to be subject to involuntary home visits from state employees--treating those parents with the same oversight and involvement that they would give parents who have abused their children.

The new regulations could consist of forced meetings with child protective services and other government agencies, which would leave the burden on the parents to prove to the government that they are fit to be parents who homeschool their children, according to the state's guidelines.

As the Washington Examiner reported, if this increase in government oversight becomes law, it would "reduce the valid legal option of homeschooling from a fundamental parental right, to direct the education and school choice for children, to compelled consent to government intrusion upon the sanctity and privacy of the home and school choice."

The push for increased government involvement is being justified by the case of David and Louise Turpin, a California couple facing 12 counts of torture after police learned that their 13 children were severely malnourished, forced to stay chained to their beds, and living in horrific conditions, among other forms of torture that have been ongoing for several years.

Instead of focusing on the tragic nature of the case, some Californians have insisted that the Turpin parents were only allowed to get away with such inhumane actions because they were registered homeschoolers--and they are also arguing that the Turpin family is not the only "homeschooled" family whose children are being tortured.

Instead of considering the fact that the majority of parents who choose to homeschool their children do so because they have no faith in the public school system, the editorial board of the Sacramento Bee argued that in the same way parents choose not to vaccinate their children, the homeschooling movement "grew as an offshoot of counterculture, religious and libertarian interests."

Since last weekend's arrest of David and Louise Turpin on suspicion of torture and child endangerment, Californians have wondered how such a thing could have gone for years undetected. The answer is that the couple exploited California's lax home schooling laws to keep the authorities from finding out what they were doing to their kids.

California law requires children aged 6 to 18 to attend a full-time school, either public or private. But there's a loophole for parents who want sole control over their children's education: Merely by filing an affidavit, they can register their homes as private schools.

However, an editorial from the Washington Examiner claimed that forcing parents who homeschool their children to adhere to the same regulations as parents who have been convicted of child abuse is "absurdly unconstitutional."

When reviewing data from some of the most revered psychological institutions in the country, the Examiner argued none of the sources listed "homeschooling as a risk factor for child abuse and neglect. In other words, there is no evidence or data to even suggest that homeschooled children are being harmed or at risk of harm at a rate higher than children in other non-homeschooled and private schooling communities."
These kinds of alarming 'solutions' to an unfounded problem rises to the level of a government search of the family's home and interviews of children, under the pretext that homeschool choice infers that parents are more likely to be child abusers.

It's a similar illogical path as inferring that because a person chooses to be an independent contractor as a legitimate employment option, they are more likely to evade tax filings, or because a person chooses to exercise any other valid legal option, they are doing so for some other unrelated nefarious purpose, and on that basis alone the government has grounds to treat them as suspect.

Requiring parents who homeschool their children to be subjected to involuntary home visits would also interfere with their constitutional rights against warrantless searches.  Why should government agencies be given authority over law-abiding parents who make the legal choice to homeschool their children?

Originally published at Free Though Project - reposted with permission.

Other News

March 15, 2018Beyond Fake News - Fake Video Could Make You Question Everything You See

New technology with the ability to create hyper-realistic fake videos has the potential to wreak havoc on the political landscape, lawmake...

March 15, 2018My University Stripped A Campus Ministry Of Recognition, Until It Fought Back

Wayne State University recently made headlines for de-recognizing a Christian student group as a sanctioned campus organization. Why? Simp...

March 15, 2018Gallup Poll Finds Highest US Support For Israel Since 1990's

A Gallup poll released on Tuesday found a surge in American support for Israel that hasn’t been seen since the early 1990's....

March 15, 2018Researchers Say Smart Home Devices Can Be Hacked, Then Spy On Its Users

Baby monitors, air conditioners, robot floor cleaners, cameras and doorbells can be corrupted by malware and used to spy on users....

March 14, 2018Turkey To Lead Islamic Army Of 57 Muslim Nations Against Israel?

A Turkish newspaper with connections to President Erdogan has called on the 57 member states of the OIC to form a joint "Army of Islam" to...

March 14, 2018'Happy You Day': Mother's Day Cards Go Gender-Neutral In UK

A grocery chain in the United Kingdom has drawn media attention for selling gender neutral Mother’s Day cards to make the day more "transg...

March 14, 2018Trump Fires Tillerson: Good For Israel, Bad For Iran

Replacing Tillerson at the State Department is CIA director Mike Pompeo, who has long been known for his hawkish views on Iran and warm ti...

Get Breaking News