ARTICLE

Christian Opposition To Israel Requires A Christian Response

News Image By Dexter Van Zile/Algemeiner.com November 20, 2018
Share this article:

It's not that Israel and the Jewish community do not have any friends in the American Protestant mainline. They do. The problem is that these friends keep losing the fights at the national gatherings of mainline churches. 

They fight well enough to remind Jewish friends and observers that they are still on the job, but not well enough to stymie or defeat the anti-Israel propagandists who have hijacked the prophetic voices of the mainline churches.


Given their dependent status, Jewish leaders in the United States are not in any position to complain about the ineffective response offered by their friends and allies in the Christian world, but they can no longer kid themselves about what has happened in the American mainline. And neither can Christians themselves.

Despite the strenuous efforts of both Christians and Jews, mainline churches have become persistent sources of anti-Jewish invective in American society, and therefore cannot speak credibly in opposition to the rising tide of antisemitic violence that has manifested itself the Middle East, Europe, and most recently the US.

This is a bad thing.

Mainline churches are clearly not the force they once were, but even in the face of their decline, they should have been well-positioned to offer the American left a well-placed warning about the dangers of antisemitism to the body politic. But given what has happened in these churches, the leaders there cannot offer this badly needed corrective. Their churches are part of the problem, and have been for a long time.

The Presbyterian Church USA is the best, but not the only, example of this phenomenon. Pro-Israel activists in the denomination operating under the banner of Presbyterians for Middle East Peace (PFMEP) have been unable to block the passage of anti-Israel overtures put forth by the Israel-Palestine Mission Network (IPMN), which over the years has produced anti-Israel and anti-Jewish propaganda worthy of Der Stürmer.


PFMEP has also been unable to achieve the passage of overtures that would highlight the threats to Israel's safety in the region. At the denomination's General Assembly (GA), which took place in St. Louis last summer, activists associated with IPMN were able to flood the agenda with resolutions highlighting Israel's alleged misdeeds, while PFMEP was only able to get two "balanced" overtures on to the agenda of the GA. Most of the IPMN overtures were approved in committee, and then passed by the GA's plenary.

At one point during the GA, one overture was amended to state that the assembly did not "condone" the incitement offered by Hamas in the Gaza Strip, but even this reference to Hamas was removed prior to the final vote -- on the grounds that there was incitement on both sides of the conflict. Talk about adding insult to injury.

One egregious demonstration of incitement came from anti-Israel activists at the GA, who said hateful things about Bassem Eid, a human rights activist who was invited to speak at the gathering by PFMEP. Eid was harassed in the convention center and on the streets of St. Louis, and the denomination's leadership did nothing, despite vociferous complaints from PFMEP.

Further clues as to how little influence PFMEP has within the PCUSA appear in the organization's own statements. On the last day of the General Assembly, PFMEP issued a bulletin calling on the body to support the overtures as they came out of the Middle East Committee "despite disagreeing with the position the Committee took on several of the overtures."

PFMEP even praised the GA's Middle East Committee declaring, "The Committee worked hard, debated the issues thoroughly, and perfected the overtures to their liking. We see little that will be gained by the plenary attempting to re-open debate."

PFMEP admitted -- in not so many words --  that they lost the fight in committee, and had no hope of winning on the floor of the entire assembly. Instead, they concluded the best thing to do was to remain silent. That's the equivalent of waving the white flag or walking off the football field before the last whistle has blown because your team has no hopes of winning.


The day after the General Assembly ended, PFMEP issued another statement declaring that the General Assembly had "changed the tone and substance of conversations that had been going on for more than a decade" within the PCUSA, and then referred to issues that had nothing at all to do with the Middle East -- fossil fuels and the organization of the church's bureaucracy.

Unfortunately, the change in tone had nothing to do with how the denomination deals with Israel, a fact underscored by the PFMEP's own post-GA email, which stated: "The death threat issued against our dear friend Bassem Eid because of his testimony before the Middle East Issues committee is something we take very personally and very seriously. We can't let the weak response of GA officials to that scary situation stand."

To be fair, there have been some victories over the years. For example, in 2014, the PCUSA was forced to stop selling an IPMN-produced document titled "Zionism Unsettled" on its website. The denomination made this decision after the Simon Wiesenthal Center (SWC) declared that it was cutting its ties to the church's leadership in Louisville. "We are severing all dialogue with PCUSA, because of a pattern of malicious behavior on the part of church administration," said Rabbi Abraham Cooper, Associate Dean of the SWC Center in Los Angeles.

There's more at stake than mainline-Jewish relations. Mainline anti-Israel activists have done more than help establish an attitudinal barrier between liberal Jews and the progressive left in the US.

They have also hindered the ability of their churches to credibly attest to the Christian faith.

Originally published at Algemeiner.com - reposted with permission.




Other News

March 26, 2024US End Game Approaching - Govt Spending More Than Twice What It Is Collecting

In a world where the US is spending more than twice what it is collecting, the endgame is clear: debt collapse, and while it won’t be tomo...

March 26, 2024Hezbollah Offensive Would Be Oct. 7 On Steroids

Thousands of rockets, thousands of casualties and devastating strikes to major infrastructure, cutting off water and electricity to Israel...

March 2, 2024U.S. Falls on the Global Happiness Scale - Why Are So Many People Unhappy?

"Finland is the world's happiest country, U.S. drops to all-time low," the New York Post reported earlier this week. This was in response ...

March 26, 2024Senate Dems Call Protecting Unborn Babies 'Dangerous' and 'Extreme'

A.C. tells the justices, that no one knows the "horror of abortion," like she did. And yet, on Capitol Hill, these nightmares are what Dem...

March 25, 2024Why Is The National Guard Being Deployed During The Great American Eclipse?

The National Guard is only supposed to be deployed in emergency situations. Now we have learned that National Guard troops will be deploye...

March 25, 2024Recognize The Times - Mankind's Exponential Increase In Knowledge

The angel Gabriel reveled to Daniel that there would be three major signs that would mark the "time of the end" and only those living in t...

March 25, 2024Dangerous Delusions: Palestinian and US Muslim Views On Hamas

Ninety-three percent of Palestinians believe that Hamas did not commit atrocities during its mass invasion of southern Israel on Oct. 7, a...

Get Breaking News