ARTICLE

Identity Politics Devours Itself

News Image By Michael Brown/AskDrBrown.org July 16, 2019
Share this article:

There is a biblical principle that everything produces after its own kind. Cats produce cats. Dogs produce dogs. Apple trees produce apples. Orange trees produce oranges. Love produces love. Hate produces hate. What does identity politics produce?

It produces bigotry. It produces division. It produces a victim mentality.

We're seeing it today in the Democratic party. Joe Biden is now a racist. Nancy Pelosi is a racist. The party is reaping what it sowed. Everything is seen through the lens of identity politics.


Disagreement Characterized By Identity, Not Issues

There can be no disagreement about issues. Instead, the disagreement is based on race or ethnicity or skin color or social status.

If I'm a Hispanic woman and you differ with my position, it has nothing to do with my position. It has nothing to do with my ideology. No, you differ with me because you're anti-woman or anti-Hispanic (or, probably, both!).

If I'm a Muslim man and you take issue with my views, it has nothing to do with differences in philosophy. It's because you are an anti-Islamic bigot, plain and simple.

If I'm a Muslim man and you take issue with my views, it has nothing to do with differences in philosophy. It's because you are an anti-Islamic bigot, plain and simple.

Where does all this lead?

It leads to Kamala Harris portraying Joe Biden as an anti-busing racist. A friend of segregationists. More like a Republican than a Democrat.

This is what happens to the trusted running-mate of America's first African-American president. This is the fruit of identity politics.


AOC Accuses Pelosi of Singling Out Minorities

It leads to Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez implying that Nancy Pelosi is racist for targeting the so-called "squad," referring to AOC, Ilhan Omar (MN), Rashida Tlaib (MI) and Ayanna Pressley (MA).

Forget the fact that AOC is espousing hopelessly extreme, completely unworkable socialist positions.

No. Pelosi is pushing back against AOC because she doesn't like non-whites.

Forget the fact that Omar and Tlaib are making openly antisemitic statements.

No. Pelosi has a problem with women of color.

In AOC's own words, "When these comments first started, I kind of thought that she was keeping the progressive flank at more of an arm's distance in order to protect more moderate members, which I understood. But the persistent singling out ... it got to a point where it was just outright disrespectful ... the explicit singling out of newly elected women of color."

This is what identity politics has created. It must ultimately eat its own.

This is what happens when you build a movement based on victimology. On division. On class warfare.

This is what happens when you focus on race more than issues. Skin becomes more important than substance and outward appearance than material differences.

As expressed by Rep. Dan Crenshaw, "Madam Speaker, welcome to the true nature of identity politics -- where you're accused of being racist for no reason at all, and where intellectually lazy insults are used against you as a way to replace substantive debate of your argument or idea."

Self-Entitlement Versus Self-Sacrifice

The sword always cuts both ways. And so, when you produce a mentality of self-entitlement, in the end, it's all about me. "I deserve more! Give me more!"

You cannot cater to self-entitlement and then expect any kind of self-sacrifice.

In the same way, when you build a movement based on identity politics, which by nature divides, you cannot expect to cultivate unity. You cannot expect to bring people together across their ideological fissures. You can only expect more and more fragmentation.


And if you ride the wave of being a victim, you will soon be attacked as the victimizer. The formerly oppressed quite quickly become oppressors.

A Boston Herald headline warned, "Progressive firebrand Ayanna Pressley needs to think about her priorities."

Unfortunately, the story was written by Hillary Chabot, who is a white woman herself. Perhaps she too is bigoted? Condescending? Perhaps she writes from the viewpoint of the superior class?

Conquered by Division

This is the way identity politics thinks. This is the trap it creates for itself, the pit that it digs before its own feet.

Ironically, presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg recently condemned President Trump's alleged embrace of "peak white identity politics," claiming that such politics are "designed to drive apart people with common interests."

Yet he made these comments at "a fundraiser in Las Vegas for the LGBTQ advocacy group Human Rights Campaign," one of the classic examples of an organization based on identity politics. The irony is beyond rich.

In short, if you conquer by dividing you will ultimately be conquered by division. The fragmentation has only begun.

Originally published at AskDrBrown.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

November 19, 2026Not Just Cyberattacks: AI Chatbots Helped Plan Real-World Attacks

While headlines focus on AI-powered hackers and digital disruption, a government test has exposed a more chilling threat: chatbots that co...

November 19, 2026Disillusioned Conservatives, Don’t Let Anti-Semitic Nationalists Speak for You

The cry “Christ Is King” rang through an Irving, Texas conference as speakers promoted racial hierarchy and antisemitic conspiracy theorie...

November 19, 2026Five Years For Defending Christianity: Egypt’s Warning To The West

That is the kind of sentence many Western Christians struggle to imagine: five years behind bars for speaking about the faith. But Samaan’...

November 19, 2026Revival Behind Bars: The Gospel Is Reaching People We Gave Up On

A prison is not where most people expect to find a revival. It is where people go after wreckage has piled up: broken families, addiction,...

November 18, 2026The AI Cyberthreat: The Real Danger May Be Six Months Away

The warning may sound like something out of a science-fiction movie: artificial intelligence systems that search for weaknesses in compute...

November 18, 2026The Facial Recognition System Built To Find Terrorists Could One Day Find You

After the October 7 attacks, Israel had urgent reasons to identify the people who carried them out. But facial recognition is spreading we...

November 18, 2026Is It 'Islamophobic' To Scrutinize Radical Views Of Muslims Headed To Congress

With the election of three new Muslim congressmen and one senator representing the Democratic Party during the midterms earlier this month...

Get Breaking News