ARTICLE

The False God of Feelings: Mayor Buttigieg's Pro-Gay Christianity

News Image By John Stonestreet/Breakpoint.org April 23, 2019
Share this article:

I've said before on BreakPoint that if your God never tells you to do anything you don't want to do, your god is probably you. If there were an Americanized translation of the Apostle's Creed for today, it would be something like this: "I believe in God the Father, Almighty, who always supports my feelings."

This kind of self-centered faith is epidemic both within the church and without, in conservative congregations and progressive ones.


The most recent case in point is Democratic presidential candidate and South Bend, Indiana mayor, Pete Buttigieg. At a recent fundraiser, he said of his same-sex "marriage": "[it] has made me a better man [and]...moved me closer to God. If being gay was a choice, it was a choice that was made far above my pay grade."

He then added, somewhat out-of-the-blue: "That's the thing I wish the Mike Pences of the world would understand, that if you have a problem with who I am, your problem is not with me. Your quarrel, sir, is with my creator."

This was, of course, a political cheap shot. Mike Pence's anti-LGBTQ reputation was secured a long time ago when, as governor of Indiana, he supported religious freedom legislation that sent progressives into hysterics (even though it was a mirror state-level copy of federal legislation that Bill Clinton and Ted Kennedy had proposed).

As Mayor Pete and the long list of Democratic presidential contenders gear up for their primaries, they have to pander to their liberal base. And what better way to do that than bashing the guy whose boss you hope to unseat? For his part, Vice-President Pence refused the bait, offering compliments instead for Mayor Pete's years of public service and adding, "He knows me better than that."


But Mayor Pete's comments are worth thinking through, if for no other reason than it would've been unthinkable not that long ago to try to enlist God in support of homosexual relationships. Feelings have become so central to personal identity across our culture, even in religion, that to suggest the Bible, God, the Church, or any other authority has a right to question those feelings is tantamount to heresy.

Buttigieg and authors like Matthew Vines, who wrote the book, "God and the Gay Christian," are in essence saying, "God made me this way--and I know this because He would never ask me to go against my feelings."

Unsurprisingly, the secular press has claimed that this new culturally-conformed Christianity as articulated by Mayor Pete will, of course, win the day. Terry Mattingly at Get Religion noted USA Today's almost "evangelistic tone" in reporting Buttigieg's words, and how they wrote as if the mayor's reading of the Bible is a defensible theological position.

The reality, of course, is that the mayor's quarrel isn't with Mike Pence. His quarrel is with the clear texts of Scripture that both identify what marriage is and what it is for, as well as how homosexual behavior is sinful. His quarrel is with natural law, reflected in the biological roles our bodies play and the universally embraced connection of marriage and procreation, even by societies not influenced by Christian morality. And of course, his quarrel is with 2,000 years of unanimous Christian witness on marriage and sexual morality.


As Everett Piper wrote at the Washington Times in reply to Mayor Pete, we don't get to make up our own version of Christianity. The faith delivered once for all is a faith delivered--it was delivered to the saints. It's a revealed faith. The religions we make up based on our feelings are different religions altogether.

Buttigieg may feel that his same-sex relationship has somehow brought him closer to God, but it has not. "If you love me," Jesus says in John 14:15, "you will keep my commandments." Now, gay people aren't singled out by Jesus' words here, but they are absolutely included.

And to be clear, Mike Pence's feelings on the issue aren't of any more authority than Mayor Pete's feelings. No, this decision was made way above either man's pay grade.

Originally published at Breakpoint.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

February 14, 2020Lessons We Have Learned From The Coronavirus

The pandemic might be an opportunity for the elites, but it is also a learning experience for the rest of us, and it might even bring some...

February 14, 2020Putting A Face On "Choice" - Abortion Survivors Put Democrats Platform To Shame

When 44 leaders of this country walked to the Senate floor last February and voted to make newborn-killing legal, our country crossed into...

February 14, 2020Why Young Europeans Can't Understand Israeli Settlers

In my experience, the incomprehension of Jewish yearning for the land of Israel is a recurring phenomenon with young Europeans--the standa...

February 14, 2020Replacement Theology - Diving Christian Support For Israel

Christians are arguably the most committed supporters of Israel in the world. At the same time, different kinds of Christians are among th...

February 13, 2020Wormwood Warning - Another Asteroid Close Approach Confirmed

In the Book of Revelation chapter eight we are warned that one day this earth will experience a devastating encouter with an object from s...

February 13, 2020Conservative In Name Only? Lawmakers Give In To The Trans Agenda

Amazingly, against all research, testimony, and common sense, five legislators in committee voted to kill a measure that would give teenag...

February 13, 2020Iran's Strategic Mistake: Too Many Enemies

Throughout history, the art of choosing one's enemies -- and, even more importantly, limiting their number, has helped dictate which leade...

Get Breaking News