ARTICLE

Give The Black Hebrew Israelites A State?

News Image By Stephen Flatow/JNS.org December 26, 2019
Share this article:

In the wake of the Jersey City massacre, the public is learning about the killers' insane anti-Semitic conspiracy theory concerning the medieval kingdom of the Khazars. But the Jersey City murderers are not the only ones who push that lunatic idea. In fact, it has been promoted by one very prominent foreign leader.

The Anti-Defamation League examined the Facebook page of Jersey City killer David Anderson and reported that "numerous posts in this Facebook account illustrate Anderson's hatred for Jews, whom he sometimes refers to as Khazars--a reference to an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory that modern Jews are descendants of an Eastern European tribe from the 11th century." In some of the posts, Anderson referred to Ashkenazi Jews as "NAZIS--ASHKE-NAZIS (KHAZARS)."


The Khazars were a semi-nomadic Turkic tribe whose leaders are said (by some sources) to have converted to Judaism in the eighth century C.E. There is no evidence that the masses of Khazaris became Jews. However, beginning in the 1930s, some anti-Zionists claimed that contemporary Jews have no right to the Land of Israel because they are descendants of the Khazars, not the original inhabitants of the land.

It's not hard to understand why the Khazar quackery appeals to a fringe cult like the "Black Hebrew Israelites," with which the Jersey City murderers identified. The core of their belief is that they are the "real" Jews. Hence they must deny that actual Jews are, in fact, Jews. Calling them Khazars thus has a strong appeal.

But Anderson and his ilk are not alone. It's also very appealing to the Palestinian Arabs--and not just to a few fringe Palestinian conspiracy theorists, but to the mainstream elected leaders who, we are constantly being told are "peaceful" and "moderate."


Just last year, Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas delivered a major public address based on the Khazar conspiracy theory. Apologists for the Palestinian cause can't claim that he was making off the cuff, passing remarks to some unimportant little group. Abbas was speaking to the P.A. National Council in the P.A. capital city of Ramallah. It was as official as official can be.

The P.A. head was explaining why the Jews have no right to the land of the biblical patriarchs Abraham and Jacob. "Khazar was a kingdom with no religion, then they became Jews, and left the kingdom and spread all over Europe," said Abbas. "And those are Ashkenazi Jews, which means they are not Semitic, and have no relation to Semitism and have nothing to do with the prophets Abraham or Jacob."

Everybody--I mean, everybody--acknowledged that the speech was anti-Semitic.

The New York Times reported that the speech "was laced with deep anti-Semitic tropes." The United Nations' "coordinator for the Middle East peace process," Nickolay E. Mladenov, said "such statements are unacceptable, deeply disturbing. ... Leaders have an obligation to confront anti-Semitism everywhere and always, not perpetuate the conspiracy theories that fuel it."

Even J Street, which functions as the de facto lobby for the Palestinian cause in Washington, D.C., called it anti-Semitic. Abbas's speech "featured absurd anti-Semitic tropes and deeply offensive comments on the history the Jewish people and Israel," a J Street press release acknowledged.


Nobody in his right mind would suggest giving the Black Hebrew Israelites an independent, sovereign state. That's because we all know that lunatics who espouse anti-Semitic conspiracy theories sometimes put their anti-Semitism into practice. Violently.

So why is giving the Palestinian Authority a sovereign state--in Israel's backyard--any safer than giving such a state to the Jersey City killers?

The elected Palestinian Arab leaders, just like the Black Hebrew Israelites, really believe that the Jews are Khazari imposters and many other insane conspiracy theories as well, such as the theory that the Palestinians are descendants from the ancient Canaanites and the idea that the Holocaust is a Zionist hoax.

So every time some well-meaning politician mouths the slogan "two-state solution," let's remind them: You wouldn't hand a loaded gun to a raving lunatic. You wouldn't hand your car keys to someone who is drunk or on drugs. And you shouldn't give an independent state to violent, anti-Semitic conspiracy theorists.

Because lives are at stake.

Originally published at JNS.org - reposted with permission.




Other News

November 17 ,2026A Nation On Edge: The Incredible Timing Of Today’s National Emergency Alert

The alert is only a test but when email, banking, and air travel are disrupted in such a short period of time, it’s hard not to wonder how...

November 17, 2026Jewish Priests Train For Temple Service As Hanukkah Approaches

If Temple worship returns, who will be ready to serve? Jewish priests are now training for that day, learning the duties their ancestors o...

November 17, 2026Canadian Lab Ordered To Pay $32k For 'Misgendering' People

The BC Human Rights Tribunal has positioned itself as the enforcer of transgender ideology, a parallel court that cannot imprison people b...

November 17, 2026Christians Still Being Fired For Expressing Private Views Online

The Trump administration has been asked to investigate after a reverend was fired from a Michigan hospice center for posting his beliefs o...

November 14, 2026How Much Longer Can Americans Keep Borrowing Their Way To Survival?

Americans are drowning in record debt, borrowing just to afford the basics while the American Dream slips further out of reach. With house...

November 14, 2026Calvary Chapel Divided: Women Pastors And The Battle Over Biblical Authority

The church that helped ignite the Jesus Movement is now at the center of a growing theological firestorm. Chuck Smith’s own grandson has a...

November 14, 2026First Britain, Now America? Growing Campaign To Criminalize Criticism Of Islam

Britain has already shown the dangers of policing speech. Now New Jersey is raising the stakes. Could criticizing Islam soon make American...

Get Breaking News